The Long and Eventful History of the Miraculous Icon of Our Mother of Perpetual Help

(Fall-Winter, 2005)
by Sr. Mary Agatha, CMRI

The following is the fascinating story, dating back more than 500 years, of the miraculous icon which the Blessed Virgin herself commanded to be venerated between the churches of St. Mary Major and St. John Lateran in Rome.

The icon of Our Mother of Perpetual Help is one of the most well-known and loved images of the Blessed Virgin known to Catholics. For many years, a weekly holy hour or novena in honor of Our Mother of Perpetual Help was common in many parish churches all over the world, and indeed, the custom continues in many places to this day.

The history of the original icon, which is now enshrined in the Redemptorist Church of St. Alphonsus in Rome, can be traced back to the year 1495, when the image, already considered ancient, was enshrined in a church on the island of Crete. When the island was threatened by Turks, the icon was carried off — possibly stolen — by a merchant who took it with him to Rome. Shortly after arriving there, the man became grievously ill. Before his death he begged a friend to take the icon to one of the churches in Rome so that it could be publicly venerated.

Upon his death, however, the friend’s wife persuaded her husband to allow her to keep the painting in their home, where it remained for several months. One night the Blessed Virgin appeared to the man in a dream, warning him not to keep the picture. Twice she appeared to him with this message, and both times he disregarded her warning. The third time she told him that if he continued to disobey her, he would die a miserable death. This time the man tried to persuade his wife to give up the painting, but she refused. Our Lady appeared to the man again to tell him of his impending death; within a short time, he became sick and died.

Miracles Begin Once the Blessed Virgin’s Directions for the Icon are Heeded

Our Lady then appeared to the man’s 6-year-old daughter, telling her to tell her mother, “Holy Mother of Perpetual Help commands you to take her out of your house!” The mother, who had seen a similar vision, was terrified and was about to give the picture to a church when a neighbor woman persuaded her that it was just a dream and that she should pay no attention to it. That night the neighbor became violently ill, and recognizing her fault, made a solemn promise to the Lady of the picture, whereupon she was immediately cured. Again the Blessed Virgin appeared to the young girl, this time commanding her to tell her mother to place her picture in a certain church between St. Mary Major’s and St. John Lateran’s. That very day, March 27, 1499, the picture was taken in solemn procession to the church of St. Matthew the Apostle, where it was placed above the exquisite white-marble altar. The church itself was very small — only about 75 feet long and 35 feet wide. Nevertheless, the shower of miraculous graces began even before the image entered its walls, with a paralyzed man being cured as the procession passed by his house.

Holy Mother of Perpetual Help insisted that her icon be publicly venerated in Rome between St. John Lateran and St. Mary Major, image Via Wikimedia.

The history of the image up to this point was written in both Latin and Italian on a large piece of parchment, which for many years was hung next to the icon in St. Matthew’s Church. Copies of the parchment are now kept in the Vatican Library.

The Mother of Perpetual Help Icon Escapes Napoleon with the Help of Augustinian Monks

For the next three hundred years, this humble church was one of the most popular pilgrimage places in Rome because of the miraculous picture. Then in 1798, the Church of St. Matthew was leveled to the ground by Napoleon’s forces. The Augustinian monks who were caretakers of the church took the picture with them, but for 64 years it was lost to the rest of the world. Eventually even the monks forgot that the image had once been regarded as miraculous.

One of the monks, Brother Augustine, who had had a great devotion to the miraculous image as a young religious, later recognized it in the monastery of Santa Maria in Posterula when he was transferred there in 1840. He would often tell Michael Marchi, one of the altar boys he was training, “Do you see that picture, Michael? It is a very old picture. Know Michael, the Madonna from St. Matthew’s is the one that hangs here in the chapel… Always remember this.”

Br. Augustine Orsetti beckons the young Michael Marchi and says: “Take a good look at this holy Madonna; She is ‘Our Lady of Perpetual Help'”. Religious pamphlet, De Volks Missionaris, 15 November 1916, via Wikimedia.

And he did remember, even well after he entered the Redemptorists in 1855. As a young priest Fr. Marchi lived at the generalate of the order, which, along with the Church of St. Alphonsus, was built on the same piece of land on which the Church of St. Matthew once stood. One day while the community was at recreation, he had the opportunity of sharing this recollection from his youth with his fellow religious. One of the priests mentioned that he had learned that a miraculous image of the Blessed Virgin had once been venerated in the Church of St. Matthew which once stood there, but that it had been lost many years earlier. At this Fr. Marchi broke in: “But it is not lost! I know that picture — it is called Our Mother of Perpetual Help. I saw it often during the years of 1850 and 1851 when I was a young student. It is in the chapel of the Augustinian monastery of Santa Maria in Posterula.” Father went on to explain what Brother Augustine had often told him about the image and its origin.

The Redemptorists now knew where the miraculous picture could be found, but they did not know about Our Lady’s command. The time had not come for the icon to come out of obscurity.

A Jesuit Priest Calls for the Icon to be Returned and Honored at the Location Specified by the Blessed Virgin

It was several years later, because of a sermon given by a Jesuit priest in one of the churches of Rome, that the icon was finally returned to the place where Our Lady wished it to be honored. On February 7, 1863, Fr. Francis Blosi gave a sermon about several of the famous pictures enshrined in the churches of Rome. Among them he described the miraculous painting of Our Lady of Perpetual Help that was once enshrined in the Church of St. Matthew. He appealed to his listeners that anyone there who might know its whereabouts should remind its possessor that the Blessed Virgin had commanded that it be honored between the Basilicas of St. Mary Major and St. John Lateran. When the Redemptorists heard this, they went to their superior general, Fr. Nicolas Mauron, begging him to procure the picture from the Augustinians for their church, which stood on the site of the old Church of St. Matthew.

Pope Pius IX Entrusting the Icon of Our Mother of Perpetual Help to the Redemptorists, Interior, Basilica of Our Lady of Perpetual Help, Boston, Massachusetts, via Wikimedia.

On December 11, 1865, Fr. Mauron obtained an audience with Pope Pius IX and laid the matter before him. After hearing the story, the Pope was convinced that it was God’s Will that the icon again be given public veneration in the location specified by the Blessed Virgin. According to tradition, this was when Pope Pius IX told the Redemptorist Superior General: “Make her known throughout the world!” Taking the written account of Fr. Marchi, which Fr. Mauron had brought with him, the Pope turned it over and wrote:

December 11, 1865
The Cardinal prefect will call the Superior of the little community of Santa Maria in Posterula and will tell him it is Our will that the Image of the most holy Mary, of which this petition treats, be returned between St. John’s and St. Mary Major’s. However, the Superior of the Congregation of the Most Holy Redeemer is obliged to substitute another suitable picture.
Pope Pius IX

The Augustinians were stunned to see the note from the Holy Father, for they had no idea that what a treasure they had had in their possession. Although they were sad to see the picture leave their monastery, they rejoiced to see it returned to the place where the Blessed Virgin desired it to be honored. In place of the original picture, they were given an exact replica within a short time.

The Redemptorists were thrilled to receive the miraculous image, but wishing to give it a fitting welcome, delayed its installation in the church until it could be cleaned and repaired, and other suitable preparations could be made. Finally, on April 26, 1866, the solemn procession and the formal enthronement of the icon took place. Along the procession route the buildings and the roadsides were decorated with flowers, vines and banners. Once again Our Lady showed her pleasure at the love shown her by her children by an outpouring of grace, for several miraculous cures took place that day. When the procession returned to the church, the icon was enshrined over the main altar amid much rejoicing.

For three days the celebration continued, with beautiful High Masses, Benediction, special devotions and sermons each day. As the word of the miracles spread, people came by the hundreds to see the picture and honor the Blessed Virgin. Soon the whole front of the church was filled with abandoned crutches and canes and other ex votos, tokens left in thanksgiving for cures. Not even two weeks had passed when Pope Pius IX himself came and spent many long moments praying before the image. “How beautiful she is!” he said, after gazing at the picture. Later, when the Arch-confraternity of Our Lady of Perpetual Help was formed, the Pope insisted that his would be the first name on the list of members.

On May 12, 1867, the Vatican ordered that the icon should be crowned. On June 23 of that year, after a Solemn High Mass, amid joyful hymns, two golden, jewel-encrusted crowns were blessed, with one crown being placed on the head of the Blessed Virgin and the other on the head of the Infant Jesus. The icon’s popularity among Eastern Rite Catholics was emphasized by the presence of the Latin Patriarch of Constantinople, who presided at the ceremony.

The original copied image of Our Mother of Perpetual Help from the Boston area mission church, now enshrined at the Boston Basilica of Our Lady of Perpetual Help, via Wikimedia.

How did the devotion to Our Mother of Perpetual Help get started in the United States?

Devotion to Our Mother of Perpetual Help spread quickly to the United States. When the Redemptorists established a mission church near Boston, they dedicated it to Our Lady under this title and were privileged to receive from Rome the first copy of the icon which had been touched to the original and blessed.1 On Pentecost Sunday, May 28, 1871, the icon was carried in a magnificent procession to the church, where it was enshrined above the main altar. As with the original image in Rome, no sooner had the painting been displayed for public veneration than the miracles began. Soon the small wooden church was thronged with so many devotees of Our Mother of Perpetual Help that it soon became necessary to begin construction of a new, larger church. But even the large beautiful new church which was dedicated in 1878 could not hold the thousands who flocked to the miraculous image in those early years — and rightly so! Between the years of 1871 and 1884, according to Fr. John Byrne, C.SS.R., “no less than 331 well-authenticated cures had been reported, some of which had been wrought in favor of people living so far away as West Virginia and Texas.”2 In 1886 alone, from January 1 to May 31, he continues, “thirty-one cures, apparently beyond the power of nature to effect, were reported.” A few years later, seven cures were reported to have taken place on a single day, the Feast of the Immaculate Conception, December 8, 1891.

St. Alphonsus Liguori Church in St. Louis, Missouri, was the first in the United States to host weekly devotions to Our Mother of Perpetual Help, image via Wikimedia.

The weekly devotions in honor of Our Mother of Perpetual Help is a custom that was introduced in 1922 at St. Alphonsus Church in St. Louis, Missouri, which at one point drew as many as eighteen thousand people every week. The devotion spread quickly from church to church until eventually, in St. Louis as in New Orleans, Detroit, Chicago, and Boston, it became necessary to schedule eight to ten services a day to accommodate all the people who wanted to honor Our Lady under this title. 3 Before long the custom of weekly devotions in honor of Our Mother of Perpetual Help had spread worldwide.

Our Mother of Perpetual Help’s Image is an example of a class of icons called Cardiotissa

The icon of Our Mother of Perpetual Help is an example of the Western influence on Eastern art. Especially in the 12th and 13th centuries, as Franciscans traveled through the eastern Mediterranean, this influence became evident in a new class of icons called Cardiotissa, from the Greek word kardia, which means heart. Cardiotissa, then, refers to a type of icon which shows tenderness, compassion, and mercy. Our Lady’s face, though serene and dignified, shows great sorrow in contemplating the sufferings of her Son.

Still, for those who are accustomed to Western art, it isn’t always easy to appreciate the beauty of an icon without understanding more about this form of art. To a Catholic of an Eastern rite, an icon is not simply an artistic representation. Once it is blessed, it becomes a window to heaven, a point of contact, “so that in praying before it, one is in the spiritual presence of the person represented. Reverently kissing the icon, one kisses the personage; bowing before it, one bows before the personage” (Robert Lane, “Russia and the Icon,” Reign of Mary #117, p. 5). An artist about to paint an icon prepares himself spiritually by prayer, confession, Holy Communion and sometimes fasting. He prays even while painting, for he sees himself as an instrument of the Holy Ghost, the principal artist, Who will use the icon as an instrument to channel graces to those who reverence it and pray before it. In most cases, the artist does not even sign his name to his work.

O Mother of Perpetual Help, grant that I may ever invoke thy most powerful name, which is the safeguard of the living and the salvation of the dying. O purest Mary, O sweetest Mary, let thy name henceforth be ever on my lips. Delay not, O Blessed Lady, to help me, whenever I call on thee; for, in all my temptations, in all my needs, I shall never cease to call on thee, ever repeating thy sacred name, Mary, Mary. O what consolation, what sweetness, what confidence fills my soul when I utter thy sacred name, or even only think of thee. I thank the Lord for having given thee, for my good so sweet, so powerful, so lovely a name. But I will not be content with merely uttering thy name. Let my love for thee prompt me ever to hail thee, Mother of Perpetual Help!

In Western art, there is little difference in the styles used in sacred art as compared to secular art; only the subject matter is different. Icons, however, are not meant to be realistic as far as physical representations, but rather to portray eternal truths in a way that immediately transports the viewer to a spiritual plane. Perhaps the simplest way to describe it is as “theology in line and color.”4 The images are rendered in an extremely stylized, non-naturalistic way. The folds of garments appear as simple geometric forms, while faces and bodies show portray human nature transformed by grace into the divine.

How does one interpret the icon of Our Mother of Perpetual Help?

In the icon of Our Mother of Perpetual Help, the Child Jesus is not portrayed with the physical proportions of an infant, but appears almost as an adult in miniature form. This has been interpreted to indicate that He is God, having infinite knowledge. Yet He is human as well, for He clings to His Mother’s hand in fear, while gazing up toward the angel over His shoulder. One of His sandals has come loose, indicating the haste with which He had run to her.

Why is the Child Jesus so frightened? The angels in the picture are holding instruments of His Passion and death, with the angel on the left bearing the gall, the lance and the reed, while the angel on the right holds the cross and nails. Their hands are covered with a cloth or veil, much like the humeral veil that the priest holds when blessing with the Blessed Sacrament in the monstrance at Benediction.

The face of Our Lady is grave and sorrowful, with her large eyes directed not at Jesus, but at us. One feels that she is pleading with us to avoid sin, which has caused her Son to suffer so much for us. Her gaze makes us a part of the picture and the pain it portrays. “Will you not love my Son, Who has loved you so much?” she seems to say.

Our Lady is clothed in the colors of royalty; her tunic is of dark red and her mantle is dark blue with a green lining. (According to another interpretation, the dark red is said to be the color worn by virgins at the time of Christ, while blue was the color worn by mothers in Palestine.) The Child Jesus also wears the colors of royalty. Both Jesus and Mary have golden halos, but Christ’s halo is decorated with a cross as a sign of His Divinity. Jeweled crowns were placed on the heads of both Mother and Child of the original icon by order of the Vatican in 1867. (The crowns were removed when the icon underwent restoration in the 1990’s.)

The Greek initials next to the head of Our Lady identify her as “Mother of God,” while those next to the Child are the abbreviation for “Jesus Christ.” The letters over the angels’ heads indicate the one on the left as St. Michael and the one on the right as St. Gabriel.

The 8-pointed star on Our Lady’s veil tells us that she is the Star of the Sea, the Star that leads us to Jesus. The small ornate cross to the left of the star reinforces this concept.

Mary’s mouth is small to indicate her spirit of silence and prayer. Her eyes are large, for they see all of our troubles and needs, and are always turned toward us.

Christ’s hands, turned palms down into His Mother’s, indicate that He has placed the graces of the Redemption in her keeping. Our Lady’s hand does not clasp those of her Son, but remains open, inviting us to put our hands in hers along with those of Jesus.

As in other icons, the background of the painting is gold to symbolize Heaven, where Jesus and Mary now reign in glory. This light of Heaven shines through their clothing, illuminating not only the picture itself, but those who behold it. This radiance speaks to us of God’s light and grace, strengthening and consoling us as we journey through life to our heavenly goal.

Finally, it is of no small significance that Our Blessed Mother herself referred to the icon by the title of “Holy Mary of Perpetual Help.” Surely this, along with the symbolism we see in the picture, should assure us of the loving concern and tenderness our Blessed Mother has for us, and her ardent desire to be a source of perpetual help to all who call upon her.

1 In answer to Pope Pius IX’s injunction to “make her known,” the Redemptorists commissioned several artists to paint copies of the original icon. More than 2,300 such copies, similarly touched to the original, have been sent to other houses of the order around the world. Pope Pius IX also received a copy, which he enshrined in his private chapel and was often seen kneeling before it in prayer.
2 The Glories of Mary in Boston, 1921.

A much-needed restoration of the CMRI sisters’ Mother of Perpetual Help Icon leads to a surprising discovery

The Sister knelt in the darkness of St. Michael’s Convent chapel before the shrine of Our Mother of Perpetual Help. How she loved to come here in the quiet evenings to pour out her heart to her Heavenly Mother! There was something special about this icon that had drawn her from the first time she saw it — perhaps it was the sorrow in Our Lady’s eyes, but she couldn’t say for sure. Behind her the chapel door creaked open, and a footstep and the soft rattle of rosary beads followed. A moment later the lights came on, and Sister lifted her eyes to gaze at the Virgin’s face. She froze, then blinked in confusion. The icon was gone. A picture of Our Mother of Perpetual Help was in the frame, but it was not the genuine icon with the sorrowful, searching eyes.

A few minutes later Sister was at her superior’s door. “Sister, what happened to Our Mother of Perpetual Help?” she blurted. The superior looked up and saw the alarm in the younger Sister’s face. “Oh Sister, I know — it’s so sad,” the other nun responded. “We had to take her out of the chapel. Didn’t you notice how badly the picture is deteriorating? It’s very old, and if we leave it in the chapel, the damage may become irreparable — if it isn’t already.”

To the Sisters who loved to come to kneel before the cherished icon every day the change was heartrending. But the explanation made sense. Over the years, due to aging and environmental conditions, the surface of the painting had become cracked and buckled. In some places the paint had actually crumbled into fragments and detached from the bare wood beneath. The nuns were not sure if even a professional could restore it, or, if this could be done, whether it would be affordable. In the meantime, the icon was placed in the care of Sister Mary Perpetua, who takes her religious name from the title of the image; eventually, with the blessing of her superiors, Sister took upon herself the task of searching for a professional who could repair the beloved image, as well as raising the funds necessary to pay for the restoration.

How did the icon find a home with the CMRI sisters?

Up until this time, little was known about the history of this particular painting, which, ensconced within a wooden shrine about 10 feet tall, had been given to the Congregation of Mary Immaculate Queen in the early 1970’s. A parishioner had managed to salvage it along with a number of other items from a church in Ohio that was discarding religious statues and pictures. She loaded them onto the back of a pickup and drove 2,000 miles across the country to northern Idaho. There the shrine was placed in St. Joseph’s Chapel in Coeur d’Alene, where it remained until the chapel was closed several years later.

The image was then moved to Mount St. Joseph, the Sisters’ convent in Colbert, Washington, where it was to have a prominent place in the large new chapel which was being prepared at the time. The shrine containing the icon was to be stripped of its paint and refinished to match the other wooden furnishings which were being constructed for the chapel. The Sisters, however, were dismayed to discover that beneath the thickly-coated paint the wood was badly charred; clearly, the shrine had been damaged in a fire. Refinishing it to expose the natural wood was out of the question; the only solution was to repaint it. Consequently, the entire color scheme for the chapel furnishings was changed from wood tones to white paint with gold leaf highlights.

When the Sisters moved to Mount St. Michael in 1995, the icon once again found a prominent place in their private chapel. There it remained, much loved and treasured by the Sisters, until it became necessary to remove it in an effort to keep it from further deterioration.

A disintegrating document on the back of the icon leads the nuns to write to the Redemptorists in Rome

When the image was given to Sr. Mary Perpetua for safekeeping, she took a close look at the badly-fragmented document affixed to the back of the picture. The nuns had always believed it to be a certificate of a Papal benediction, but upon closer examination, Sister saw that it was something else. The document was sealed with two Redemptorists’ wax seals; the text was in Latin, and included a signature followed by the words “Vicar General,” the date September 18–, and a handwritten number 1595. Sister enlisted the help of her fellow nuns, and a search for information was begun.

First of all, a series of digital photographs of the icon was taken, including close-ups of heavily-damaged areas as well as the document affixed to the back. The photos of the image would prove useful in the search for craftsmen trained in the art of restoration, while those of the document would be necessary to uncovering information about the history of the painting.

Since the document bore the Redemptorist seal, one of the Sisters wrote to the headquarters of the Redemptorist Order in Rome, explaining the situation and requesting a list of vicars general for the 1800’s. Within a few days the Secretary General wrote back, explaining that the Redemptorists did not institute the practice of appointing vicars general until the 1900’s. He also pointed out that the order did not receive the commission to promote devotion to the Blessed Virgin under the title of Mother of Perpetual Help in 1867, when the icon was found and placed in the Church of St. Alphonsus in Rome. This narrowed the search down to about 33 years.

Encouraged by this reply, the Sisters emailed the photos of the icon and the document to the Secretary General. Soon a reply came with additional information that had been found in the archives about the painting. Shortly after the Pope had commissioned the Redemptorists to spread devotion to Our Mother of Perpetual Help, two or three artists were employed to paint reproductions of the original miraculous icon. About 2,300 were painted, and each was numbered and authenticated with a signed document. The number, 1595, which still appears clearly on the document on the back of the image, indicates that it is the 1,595th painting to be sold. The icon, which was executed in the time-honored technique traditionally used in painting icons, that of egg tempera1 on wood, is the exact size of the original in the Church of St. Alphonsus in Rome. A record of the sale found in the General Archives of the order indicates that the purchase was made on September 7, 1893, and the painting was mailed later that month to an address in Baltimore, although it was eventually destined for a church in Cincinnati.

The fragmented document affixed to the back of the picture attests to the fact that it is one of the 2,300 replicas of the original miraculous icon that the Redemptorists commissioned in the late 1800’s

The nuns’ persistence is rewarded when the mystery of the document’s signature is solved

All that remained to be explained now was the signature on the document. Fr. Nicholas Mauron was the Superior General of the Redemptorists from 1855 until his death in July of 1893. The next Superior General was not elected until the following March. Thus the purchase of the painting was made at a time when there was no Superior General in office. Fr. Mauron, however, perhaps because of declining health, had appointed one of his consultors, Fr. Matthias Raus, to be his Vicar General in October 1892. The signature on the painting is actually that of Fr. Franz Xavier Reuss, the personal secretary to Fr. Mauron and also to Fr. Raus, who signed in the name of the Rev. Father Vicar General (Pro Rev. P. Vicario Generalis, P. Franc. X. Reuss).

Meanwhile, Sister Mary Perpetua had located a company on the East coast specializing in restoring and appraising icons. On June 21, 2004, the precious icon, carefully wrapped and packaged, was shipped. The process, which took about four months, involved cleaning the painting, filling in damaged areas, and painting and retouching these areas in the original colors. Fragments that had become loose were carefully replaced and fixed into place with special adhesives, and any remaining cracks were filled and painted. The icon arrived back at the convent on October 28, 2004. The nuns breathed a sigh of relief to see how beautifully the image had been repaired. Our Lady had come home, and soon the Sisters could once kneel before her shrine and pour out their hearts before her.

Thou hast been made for us, O Lady,
a Refuge,
A Helper in need and tribulation.

1 The technique of egg tempera dates back to Babylon, although it was not perfected until the the last century of the Byzantine Empire (400 A.D.-1202 A.D.). The paint is made from pigments mixed with egg yolk and water. The yellow from the yolk bleaches out within a day or two. Unlike oil paint, egg tempera does not fade, yellow, or change color over time. Because it is brittle when dry, it must be painted on a rigid surface, traditionally a panel of wood covered with a white, slightly absorbant plaster-like surface called gesso.

–Taken from the Reign of Mary Quarterly Magazine, Issue 120

Share it!


One Response

  1. This is a really really beautiful post! Thank you so much! I have had a chronic recurrent bacterial infection for the past four years and I have been trying to pursue priesthood but have been too sick to do such, sadly. This June I began to pray three prayers to Saint Alphonsus and Our Mother of Perpetual Help for all those I love. As the month drew on I found myself more and more in love with the devotion and the title without ever having read up on it. I purchased an icon touched to the original and placed it in my room. I have so much hope that Our Mother of Perpetual Help will heal me. June 27th was one of only three nights in five years that I slept good and woke up refreshed and didn’t have pain…that is no coincidence! That is God and the power of Our Mother of Perpetual Help!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Picture of The Spiritual Life

The Spiritual Life

This Blog is maintained by the Ecclesiastical Administrator and other contributors

Contact us!

You have Subscribed!

From now on, you will receive our newsletter and special Notifications. Thank you!